Custom Cakes

Dreaming about enjoying a beautiful, unforgettably delicious, allergy-friendly cake?  Or truly scrumptious freshly-iced cupcakes?  Now your dream will come true when you savor your cake, custom baked for you with select ingredients by Soodles Bake Shop, your very allergy-friendly local bakery.  

Prices for strikingly delicious cakes include beautiful freehand trim and messages.  Exquisite additional freehand decoration, tailored specifically for your birthday, wedding, anniversary or other event, is available for an additional charge. 

Food at Soodles Bake Shop is 100% clean, which means we do not use any "additives, artificial flavors, artificial sweeteners, or chemical preservatives". 

To order, call or text at (614) 356-7090, or e-mail us your order with your name and phone number at [email protected] Corn-free cakes are also available upon request. 

Cake Prices for Carrot, Chocolate, Red Velvet, and Vanilla.  

Carrot Cakes:

  • 4" Smash Cake (Single Layer) - $22
  • 6" Diameter Round Double Layer Cake - $45
  • 8" Diameter Round Double Layer Cake - $55
  • 1/4 Sheet Double Layer Cake - $75
  • 1/2 Sheet Double Layer Cake - $115

 Chocolate or Vanilla Cakes:

  • 4" Smash Cake (Single Layer) - $20
  • 6" Diameter Round Double Layer Cake - $41
  • 8" Diameter Round Double Layer Cake - $51
  • 10" Diameter Round Double Layer Cake - $61
  • 1/4 Sheet Double Layer Cake - $81
  • 1/2 Sheet Double Layer Cake - $110

Red Velvet Cakes:

  • 4" Smash Cake (Single Layer) = $29
  • 6" Diameter Round Double Layer Cake = $51
  • 8" Diameter Round Double Layer Cake = $61
  • 1/4 Sheet Double Layer Cake = $81
  • 1/2 Sheet Double Layer Cake = $120

Wedding Cakes:

  • 6" Smash Cake (Single Layer) = $66
  • 8" Diameter Round Double Layer Cake = $76
  • 10" Diameter Round Double Layer Cake = $86
  • 1/4 Sheet Double Layer Cake = $106
  • 1/2 Sheet Double Layer Cake = $146

Cupcake Prices for Chocolate or Vanilla.  Additional charge for Red Velvet.

  • Mini Cupcakes = 12 for $24, 18 for $36, 24 for $46
  • Regular Cupcakes = 6 for $18, 12 for $36, 18 for $54, 24 for $70
  • Jumbo Cupcakes = 6 for $30, 12 for $60, 18 for $90
  • Red Velvet Cupcakes (Regular) = 6 for $24, 12 for $48
  • Red Velvet Cupcakes (Jumbo) = 6 for $33, 12 for $66

 Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake

  • 8" Diameter Round Cookie Cake = $13.50
  • 13" Diameter Round Cookie Cake = $31.50

Cancellation Policy:  Orders are final and non-refundable two business days before scheduled pickup date.